empty meeting room

Campbeltown Community Council

 Draft Minutes of Meeting 10th November 2026

 7.30pm in Campbeltown Town Hall

Present

Jason McCallum (Convenor)

Catriona McCulloch, Vice-Convenor

Ann Gallacher (Treasurer)

Catherine Dobbie

Jim Martin

Annette McMillan

Valerie Nimmo

Agnes Stewart

Lesley Renton

Phil Crook (Secretary)

In attendance

Cllr John Armour

Norman Weir

  1. Welcome

J McCallum took the chair, and welcomed everyone to the meeting.

  1. Apologies

Apologies were received from Elzbieta Grabowska, David Allen and Cllr Jennifer Kean.

  1. Declarations of interest

J McCallum reminded members to declare any interest they had in an agenda item as it was reached.

  1. Approval of minutes of last meeting

The minutes of the meeting of October 13th 2026 were agreed: proposed by A McMillan, seconded by A Stewart.

  1. Matters arising
  • Patient Transport. A draft list of questions has been prepared. P Crook proposed that during November and December we
    a) reach out to the neighbouring community councils (Southend, East Kintyre, West Kintyre) and get them involved. If possible we should try to include someone from Macrihanish, since Laggan CC is non-operational.
  1. b) finalise paper and on-line versions of the questions
  2. c) liaise with the health bodies about interviewing patients
  3. d) run an advertising campaign

all with the view of running the survey during January. This was agreed by the committee.

  • Sanda. V Nimmo and C Dobbie joined a MOWI trip to the proposed site of the fish farm off Sanda on Monday 9th, together with members from Southend Community Council. There was nothing in particular to report.
  • Registration with Information Commissioner. As recommended by Lynsey Innes at A&BC, we are now registered and P Crook is the nominated Data Controller.
  • Feedback from MAKI ACPG meeting. C McCulloch represented the Community Council at the meeting on November 4th. Points to note included:
    a) the Medieval Kintyre project was still stalled, waiting for access to the cemeteries to be granted by Argyll and Bute Council. Cllr Armour promised to follow this up;
    b) the meeting was updated on the Lochgilphead regeneration proposal which includes training in traditional skills;
    c) Campbeltown ambulance service has only two vehicles available for patient transport;
    d) Shopper-Aide need £1000 to keep them going until the end of the year.
  • Feedback from A&BC training session. L Renton attended the session on planning. It finished with a brief mention of Local Place Plans which are due to be sent in by the end of January. Campbeltown has not so far prepared a Place Plan since we expended a lot of effort and time on our Community Action Plan 2022-2027. We have an option of seeing if our Action Plan can be transformed into a Place Plan with some judicious cutting and pasting: however, since it expires next year, maybe more work is required. Action: for further consideration.
  1. Kintyre De-population

Norman Weir gave a presentation in which he highlighted the forecast decline in population of Campbeltown and south Kintyre. Members were struck by the “tipping points” he described, when shops, businesses, supermarkets, transport, social services, and health services gradually disappear and the town becomes a shadow of itself.

Mr Weir proposes to capitalise on this – our resident over-65 population could be an asset for health service training in the care of the elderly. A step-down health facility would relieve pressure on Glasgow hospitals while a vocational hub (part of the UHI) would focus on Rural Gerontology, Tele-Health and Assistive Robotics.

This is a big idea and needs careful thought from everyone. The meeting recommended that Mr Weir contact the Courier to run a special article on the perceived dangers of decline; in January the Community Council will join others to try to set up a working group to take the discussion further.

J McCallum warmly thanked Mr Weir for his thought-provoking presentation.

  1. Correspondence received

All correspondence has been circulated to the committee. Specific points are:

  • Representations required by November 21st for the Deucheran Hill windfarm. Action V Nimmo
  • Letter from Partick Maitland about the Picture House. Action: P Crook to respond suitably
  • Christmas Well-being support for the fishing community – this has been passed to the Wind Farm Fund.
  • Engagement with Local Government Reform. V Nimmo attended the meeting. The initial proposal sets out the view that Scotland currently has some councils that are too large to be truly local and others that are too small to operate strategically at the scale now required. It is therefore proposed a model, built around a smaller number of Strategic Regional Authorities (6-10), alongside a much larger number of Community Authorities (120-160), with bespoke arrangements for island communities. The principle is that strategic decisions should be taken at regional level, while decisions that affect everyday community life should be taken much closer to local people.

Regional authorities would be responsible for delivery of core services, education, environmental services such as waste and cleansing; civil defence, resilience and response.  Community authorities for householder planning applications, community planning, licensing decisions, as well as management of the historic environment and open space and greenspace, the regeneration of local town centres and the provision and maintenance of local leisure, sport and culture facilities.

  • Car-pooling and car-sharing survey – we do not feel Campbeltown has anything special to add.
  • Comments on clean energy principles. Action: V Nimmo to reply
  • Kintyre Seasports construction – we have no objections
  • Draft Clyde Regional Marine Plan. Action: C McCulloch will look at this
  • HSCP Simulation – no action required
  • Use of BSL – Action: P Crook to forward to Martine Craig
  • Local Development Plan part 3. Cllr Armour advised that we should engage with this. Action: P Crook to take a first look at the three documents
  1. Police report

The police report for October has not yet been received. The report for September was noted.

  1. Councillor’s report

Cllr Armour reported on a recent meeting of HITRANS who met in Campbeltown. The problems we have with rural public transport are shared by everyone. There is a chance to apply for funds under the HITRANS Employability and Access Schemes which he is investigating.

  1. Treasurer’s report

The accounts stand at:

Main account                £  9057.27

Quesada account          £  1505.20

Wind Farm Fund           £52664.34

Savings account            £20695.09

The treasurer noted that this excludes around £51,000 from the Wind Farm Fund which it was agreed to disburse following the trustees’ meeting.

  1. Communication and opinion gathering

No further discussion took place. It is subsumed into the Local Place Plan/Community Action Plan work mentioned above.

  1. Planning issues

Planning and building applications were reviewed and there were no concerns or comments.

  1. Public questions

None.

  1. AOCB

A Gallacher had a query about the wording for the CC advert on the minibus – it was agreed to use the same as before.

C McCulloch asked about the restoration of the wall at the old AIB Stewart building. Cllr Armour advised to look at the planning application to see what was specified.

V Nimmo said she had arranged for minutes of our previous meetings to be put onto our website.

  1. Date of next meeting

The next meeting will be held on Tuesday December 8th 2026 at 7.30pm at the Town Hall

The meeting ended at 9.10pm